A subject names an area. A topic narrows it. A good topic turns it into a question that a reader wants answered and that evidence can actually answer. That progression — from inflation, to inflation and housing, to has recent inflation hurt renters more than homeowners in the UAE, and why? — is where every YEL Journal article starts. It is also the first thing our editors check.
| Level | Example | Can it be approved? |
|---|---|---|
| Subject | Inflation | No. It is an area, not an article. |
| Topic | Inflation and housing | Not yet. There is no question. |
| Question | Has recent inflation hurt renters more than homeowners in the UAE, and why? | Yes, if the sources can support it. |
Source: Editor Handbook, Section 4.
A correspondent does not need to know the answer when they pitch. They do need to know the question. If they cannot state it in one sentence, with a place, a group or a period attached, the pitch goes back for revision.
Sharpening a pitch
Most first pitches come back marked Revise, and that is normal. It is far easier to fix a question than a finished draft. This is how a weak pitch becomes a workable one:
| Weak pitch | Why it fails | A workable version |
|---|---|---|
| “Why cryptocurrency is the future of money.” | Announces a conclusion; too broad. | “Why have stablecoins grown faster than other cryptocurrencies for cross-border payments, and what risks does that create for users?” |
| “AI and jobs.” | A subject, not a question. | “Which entry-level tasks in accounting are most exposed to AI tools, and what does early evidence from firms that adopted them show?” |
| “Tariffs are bad.” | Opinion with nothing to test. | “Who actually paid for a specific recent tariff: foreign exporters, domestic firms, or consumers?” |
| “The economy of Dubai.” | Far too large for 2,000 words. | “How has rapid population growth affected rents in Dubai since 2021, and what has policy done about it?” |
| “Should students learn about finance?” | Weak economic content; no evidence plan. | “Do school financial-literacy mandates change later saving or borrowing? What do studies of US states that introduced them find?” |
Source: Editor Handbook, Section 4. These are illustrations of how to sharpen a pitch, not pre-approved topics or claims about what the evidence will show.
Six tests before a word is written
- Fit. There is a clear economic, financial or policy mechanism at the centre, not just a news event or a moral argument.
- Focus. One question, with limits on place, group or time period, that can be answered in 2,000 words.
- Reader value. There is a puzzle, a trade-off, a common misunderstanding, or a timely reason to look.
- Analysis. There is room to explain incentives, causes, effects or choices, not only to list facts.
- Evidence. The named sources are credible, accessible and relevant to the specific question.
- Openness. The evidence could change the conclusion.
The six parts of a finished piece
| Part | What it should do |
|---|---|
| Headline | Reflect what the article actually finds. No clickbait, and no claim the article cannot back up. |
| Opening | Set out the question and why it matters in the first few paragraphs. A concrete example or a surprising fact is a good way in. |
| Background | Give the reader just enough context to follow the argument. This is not a textbook chapter. |
| Analysis | The bulk of the article. Each section moves the answer forward; each paragraph makes one point. |
| Counterargument and limits | Take on the strongest objection and admit what the evidence cannot show. |
| Conclusion | Answer the question and say what follows from the answer. No new evidence, and no vague call to action. |
Source: Editor Handbook, Section 7. A guide, not a template. An explainer, an analysis and an argued opinion piece can all work if the question, evidence and reasoning are sound.
What makes the analysis hold
This is what separates economics writing from reporting. It is not enough to say that higher interest rates reduced house prices. The article has to explain the chain: borrowing costs rise, monthly payments rise, fewer buyers qualify, demand falls, sellers cut prices. Of every important claim, we ask what happens first, who responds, and how does that lead to the result?
Two things happening together does not mean one caused the other. Where the evidence only shows a pattern, the wording says so — is linked to, coincided with, is consistent with. And because almost every economic change helps some people and costs others, a strong piece asks who gains, who pays, and whether the answer differs between rich and poor households, large and small firms, or the short and long run.
Checking the numbers
Every important number is checked against its source. These are the errors editors look for first:
- Totals presented as if they were per person, or the reverse.
- Nominal figures compared across years without adjusting for inflation.
- Levels confused with growth rates.
- Missing units, currency, country or year.
- Forecasts reported as if they had already happened.
- Arithmetic that does not add up. Anything the article calculates, the editor recalculates.
Percentages and percentage points
A rate that goes from 4% to 6% has risen by two percentage points — or by 50 per cent. Both are true. Only one is what the writer meant.
How a draft is scored
Every draft is scored out of 100 across six areas. Reasoning and evidence carry the most weight, because polish can hide a weak argument and a rough draft can hide a strong one. Editors judge the thinking first and the sentences second.
Sign-off normally needs 85 or more, and a high score alone is not enough. Every condition must also be met: the approved question is answered; no factual, numerical or conceptual errors remain; the strongest counterargument is addressed; every source is traceable; and every substantive comment has been answered.
Four tests any reader can run
- The summary test. After reading, can you state the question and the answer in two sentences?
- The “so what” test. Do you know something useful, or see something differently, having read it?
- The “how do you know” test. Pick the three most important claims. Can you point to the evidence behind each, and does it say what the article says it does?
- The objection test. Think of the first objection a sceptical economist would raise. Does the article deal with it?
We publish these standards so that readers can hold us to them. If a piece in the Journal fails one, write to us at info@youtheconomylab.org.
