Editorial policy
Our standards
The checks every pitch and every draft goes through. They are the same for everyone, and we publish them so that readers can hold us to them.
The standard, in one line
A YEL Journal article asks a real question in economics, finance or policy, answers it with evidence a reader can check, explains why the answer holds, and does all of this in plain language a smart non-economist can follow.
Everything else on this page is a more detailed version of that sentence. Editors are responsible for three things: the quality of the argument, the reliability of the evidence and the clarity of the writing. The article itself belongs to the correspondent.
Approving a topic
Approval is the most important decision an editor makes. A weak topic produces a weak article no matter how hard the correspondent works.
Approving a topic does not mean the article will be published. It means the question is worth answering and the correspondent has a realistic way to answer it in 1,000 to 2,000 words. Every pitch is tested against six criteria.
| Criterion | The question to ask | Approve when… |
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Is this really about economics, finance or policy? | There is a clear economic, financial or policy mechanism at the centre, not just a news event or a moral argument. |
| Focus | Is there one question, and can it be answered in 2,000 words? | The pitch names a single question with limits on place, group or time period. |
| Reader value | Why would anyone want to read this? | There is a puzzle, a trade-off, a common misunderstanding, or a timely reason to look at it. |
| Analysis | Will the article explain something, or just describe it? | There is room to explain incentives, causes, effects or choices, not only to list facts. |
| Evidence | Can the correspondent actually find the evidence? | The named sources are credible, accessible and relevant to the specific question. |
| Openness | Could the evidence change the conclusion? | The pitch asks a question rather than announcing an answer it plans to prove. |
Each pitch is marked Approved, Revise or Declined within two days, with the reason written down. Most first pitches end up at Revise, and that is normal. A topic is declined when it falls outside economics, finance or policy, duplicates another correspondent’s piece, depends on evidence that cannot be obtained, or could not be made workable through reasonable revision.
The argument
- 01
A clear question and a clear answer
By the end of the opening paragraphs, the reader knows what is being asked, where and for whom, and why it matters. The main claim is specific and no stronger than the evidence allows. “The evidence is mixed, but points toward X for these reasons” is a good answer. “It’s complicated” is not.
- 02
An explained mechanism
It is not enough to say that higher interest rates reduced house prices. The article explains the chain: what happens first, who responds, and how that leads to the result. Naming a theory is not the same as applying it.
- 03
Evidence tied to each claim
Each important paragraph makes a claim, supports it with evidence, and explains what the evidence shows. Each source supports the specific claim it is cited for.
- 04
Care with cause and effect
Where the evidence only shows a pattern, the wording says so: “is linked to”, “coincided with”, “is consistent with”. When a cited study makes a causal claim, the article says briefly how the study reached it.
- 05
Trade-offs and who is affected
Almost every economic change helps some people and costs others. Averages are not treated as if they applied to everyone.
- 06
The strongest counterargument
The article takes on the best objection, not the weakest, and explains why its reading is more convincing or admits where the question remains open. Balance does not mean equal space for claims with no evidence behind them.
Economics
Correct use of concepts, such as real versus nominal, stocks versus flows, and correlation versus causation. Clear mechanisms. Attention to who is affected.
Finance
A clear line between fact, forecast and opinion. No prediction presented as certain, nothing that reads as investment advice, and no recommendation to buy or sell. Risk discussed alongside return.
Policy
A stated goal, the mechanism by which the policy is meant to reach it, the realistic constraints, the costs, and a comparison with at least one alternative, including doing nothing.
Evidence and sources
The claims that matter most are checked first: the main argument, the headline numbers, any statement about cause, and anything said about a named person or organisation.
| Type of source | Good for | Be careful with |
|---|---|---|
| Official data (central banks, statistics offices, IMF, World Bank, OECD) | Figures, trends and definitions. | Revisions, changes in definition, and dates of release. |
| Peer-reviewed research and working papers | Evidence on causes and effects. | Whether the study’s setting matches the article’s. Working papers are not yet reviewed. |
| Laws, regulations, company filings | What a rule or company actually says or reports. | Filings show what a firm reports, not that its claims are true. |
| Reputable journalism and analysis | Context, recent events, competing views. | Numbers are followed back to the original source. |
| Think tanks and advocacy groups | Arguments and policy proposals. | Their funding and position. Paired with a source from another viewpoint. |
| Blogs, social media, AI summaries | Finding leads. | Not acceptable as evidence on their own. |
Numbers, citations and charts
Every important number is checked against its source. Editors look for:
- Totals presented as if they were per person, or the reverse.
- Nominal figures compared across years without adjusting for inflation.
- Percentages confused with percentage points. A rate going from 4% to 6% is a rise of two percentage points, or 50%.
- Levels confused with growth rates; missing units, currency, country or year.
- Forecasts reported as if they had already happened, and figures from different sources compared as if measured the same way.
- Arithmetic that does not add up. Anything the article calculates, the editor recalculates.
Every statistic, quotation and borrowed idea carries a citation placed next to it, and the reader must be able to find the exact source: author or organisation, title, date and a working link. Quotations are word for word. Citations do not count toward the word limit.
Every chart has a title, labelled axes with units, the time period and the source. Editors watch for axes that do not start at zero without good reason, time periods chosen to exaggerate a trend, and charts that imply cause when they only show a pattern.
Writing and structure
Written for a smart reader who is not an economist, in the correspondent’s own voice.
- Technical terms are explained the first time they appear. If a plain word would do, it is used.
- Each paragraph has one point, ideally stated in its first sentence.
- The article makes clear what is fact, what is interpretation and what is the author’s view.
- No loaded labels, personal attacks or sweeping claims about groups of people.
- Length is 1,000 to 2,000 words, not counting citations.
Scoring and sign-off
Each draft is scored from 0 to 5 in six areas, weighted to give a mark out of 100. The score helps editors be consistent across correspondents; it never replaces written feedback.
| Area | Weight | What a 5 looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Question and argument | 15 | A focused question, a clear and defensible answer, consistent scope. |
| Reasoning | 25 | Mechanisms explained, concepts used correctly, care with cause and effect, trade-offs considered. |
| Evidence and sources | 25 | Credible, relevant, traceable sources that support the exact claims made. Numbers correct. |
| Depth and balance | 15 | Real insight, the strongest counterargument addressed, limits acknowledged. |
| Structure and clarity | 15 | Logical order, clear explanations, readable by a non-economist. |
| Presentation | 5 | Within length, properly cited, links working. |
Sign-off normally needs 85 or more, and a high score alone is not enough. An editor signs off only when the article answers the approved question; no factual, numerical or conceptual errors remain; the strongest counterargument and main limits are addressed; every source is traceable and every chart labelled; there are no unresolved concerns about originality, AI use or unfair claims about real people; and every substantive comment has been answered. The Review Board then makes the final decision.
Integrity and AI
Integrity concerns are handled carefully and fairly. A wrong accusation can do as much damage as a missed problem.
- AI tools may not generate any of the writing. They may be used to brainstorm and to check work. AI output is never a source; any fact found through an AI tool is traced to a real, citable source. The same rule applies to editors.
- Plagiarism means removal from the programme. All work is the correspondent’s own, and every source, statistic and quotation is cited. The decision belongs to the programme directors.
- Similarity checks. Any article with a Turnitin similarity over 25 is reviewed by the programme directors, who look at what actually matched before drawing any conclusion.
- Conflicts of interest. Writers and editors disclose any personal, financial or organisational connection to a piece’s subject, and a piece is reassigned where needed.
- Claims about real people. Claims about named people or organisations need strong, citable evidence. Articles do not include private personal information or confidential documents.
Corrections
When we get something wrong, we correct it openly. A dated note is added to the foot of the article saying what was wrong and what was changed. We never quietly edit published text.
To report an error, write to info@youtheconomylab.org with the article, the passage and, where you can, the source that shows the error.
Corrections log
No corrections have been issued.
Nothing published in the YEL Journal is investment advice. Finance desk pieces draw a clear line between fact, forecast and opinion, and never recommend buying or selling anything.
